Shop Mobile More Submit  Join Login
Comment Before You Favourite by BoffinbraiN Comment Before You Favourite by BoffinbraiN
:iconcommentplz: Comment Before You Favourite by BoffinbraiN

Comment before you favourite. Comment because you care. And spread the word!

Use the icon by putting :iconcommentplz: in your journal, deviation description or comment.
Use the stamp by putting :thumb43231916: in your journal or deviation description. Thumbnails do not work in comments.

If you're going to comment here or ask a question, read the FAQ first. 90% of people don't, and they look stupid for it.




This stamp was made for livius (journal) and melonhead-emotion (journal) and those hundreds of you who agree with them.

If a deviant displays this stamp or icon in their deviation description, they are indicating that they care more about comments than favourites, and will ignore people who fave just to get attention.

Show deviants some courtesy and respect by giving them critique and feedback if they request it. Nobody can force you to comment, but we hope people will read this and consider giving something back to the artists they love. This stamp has influenced and enlightened a lot of people, who say they feel better knowing they've made contact with the artists.

If you are the kind of person that favourites more than 10 things per day, then you're not using the system as it was intended. A favourite means you consider something to be really special, and they should not be overused, or they become worthless.

Favourites should not be a way of seeking attention - this is known as fav-bombing and is not welcomed. Prove that you care by saying what you like about the piece. Critique and praise alike, comments are a form of human social interaction that favourites can never give. That's the kind of active community we want in deviantART. Which would you rather receive?



FAQ:

Can I use this stamp/icon in my submissions? Yes, you can use it anywhere on deviantART.

Does order matter? Does it matter if I favourite before I comment? Don't be silly; of course not!

What if I'm too busy to comment? Consider coming back and commenting later.

Do short comments like 'Cool' or 'Nice!' count? If the deviant has specified that they wish to receive critique, then no.

What if the artist never replies to comments? Well, it's up to you to decide if you think the artist will appreciate your comment or not.

What if I never know what to say in a comment? See below for some awesome guides on how to write constructive critique.

Why does this stamp have more favourites than comments? Because this is just a typical example of a deviation on deviantART. At least by having a high number of favourites, it's increasing awareness.



See also:
Read before you Comment - because it saves you time and possible embarrassment.
A Compromise - Can't comment on everything? Read this fantastic comic that received a Daily Deviation.
Good Comment Guide presented by bringbackart describes, as briefly as possible, what you should be looking to give when you comment.
Constructive Critique, a brief note by realitysquared that urges you to question whether your comments are benefiting the artists you frequent.

If you have a suggestion for this list, note me.
Add a Comment:
 
:iconchooniemoonie2002:
ChoonieMoonie2002 Featured By Owner Mar 12, 2016  Hobbyist Digital Artist
For me, it's a tendency because I want opinion from people I don't know (and know, too) when they fave my work.
Reply
:iconapperatus:
Apperatus Featured By Owner Mar 9, 2016
So true
Reply
:iconsideshow-cellophane:
Sideshow-Cellophane Featured By Owner Mar 7, 2016  Hobbyist Artist
I honestly have to agree. I want feedback on my work, not JUST favorites! I want to know why you liked it too! XP
Reply
:iconxsamuraiedgex:
XSamuraiEdgeX Featured By Owner Feb 20, 2016  Hobbyist Digital Artist
lol i actually fave before i comment XD
Reply
:iconsophisparklepoppin:
SophiSparklePoppin Featured By Owner Feb 16, 2016
USING
Reply
:iconxxblackbloodedsoulxx:
xXBlackBloodedSoulXx Featured By Owner Edited Feb 14, 2016  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Oh man I get how this feels, then when people do comment on my stuff alot of the time its not about the art and they just want to rp ;-; it sucks big time to think your only there for a rping buddy. Defiently will be using this awesome stamp! ;w;
Reply
:iconmatt-flame:
Matt-Flame Featured By Owner Feb 13, 2016  Hobbyist Digital Artist
cheers mate ( .D.)
Reply
:iconxxrenegade-wingsxx:
xXRenegade-WingsXx Featured By Owner Edited Feb 10, 2016  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Thanks for making this... I hate when there are some people who only fave my art but don't comment, because then I'll think they are really don't care
Reply
:iconphineasjamesvinci:
PhineasJamesVinci Featured By Owner Feb 7, 2016  Student Writer
Nice. :) Can anyone use this?
Reply
:iconboffinbrain:
BoffinbraiN Featured By Owner Feb 10, 2016  Professional Interface Designer
Yep. It's all explained in the description.
Reply
:iconphineasjamesvinci:
PhineasJamesVinci Featured By Owner Feb 10, 2016  Student Writer
Awesome thanks! :)
Reply
:iconredrosabell:
redrosabell Featured By Owner Jan 20, 2016  Professional
Can I use this?
Reply
:iconswedishfishwolf:
SwedishFishWolf Featured By Owner Jan 11, 2016
I really don't see a point in commenting if I don't have anything to say.
Like yeah, getting comments make me feel like I'm actually worth something, but when all the comments are "cool" or"cute", they too lose meaning.
Sure, critique is nice and help you improve, but when all the comments you get are just hollow, meaningless words, I'd rather take the faves.

I only really fave something if I actually like it, and as the asshole I am, never pay any attention to the people who fave my stuff. Now, don't get me wrong; I love every single person who take the time to fave my art, I really do, but I just don't see a point in thanking them for liking my art. I'm sure they know I'm really grateful anyways. So just because someone only faves, doesn't mean they don't care. 

I'd rather take one comment with c
ritique and praise alike every three months, than a lot of ass-kissers who only comment words with no true meaning behind them.
Though I do appreciate comments as a whole, I just don't want people to feel forced to comment on my stuff if they don't have anything special to say about it. 

I'm sorry, I'm just so tired of people whining about more comments, when all they'll really get are hollow words and forced compliments.
Be grateful for what you get, even if it's just faves.
Reply
:iconthenobleone15:
TheNobleOne15 Featured By Owner Jul 11, 2016  Hobbyist General Artist
I agree with you.

I favorite a lot of pictures with commenting. I rarely comment since I don't want to give a comment that is meaningless.
Reply
:iconswedishfishwolf:
SwedishFishWolf Featured By Owner Jul 11, 2016
Yeah, I feel you
I generally only ever comment on my friends works,
but if I have constructive, helpful criticism to give, I'll give it.
Just commenting 'cool', 'looks good' or 'well done' have kind
of lost its meaning to me, and as such I don't comment those things
on others work. 
Reply
:iconthenobleone15:
TheNobleOne15 Featured By Owner Jul 11, 2016  Hobbyist General Artist
I only comment when I really have something to say. Also, I sometimes find clusters of good works and thus I don't have the time to comment on them all. I tend to comment on my friends works as well. People need to know that when they get it favorite it probably means that the person liked the work so much that they added it to their favorites so that they could look at it again. I see no point in obsessing over whether the favorite was just to get attention or really genuine. When I get a favorite I just smile and delete the notification.
Reply
:iconswedishfishwolf:
SwedishFishWolf Featured By Owner Jul 11, 2016
Exactly! I add the things I think look good to my favorites, and that's it.
Just because you favorite a lot of things does not mean you're an
attention-seeker either. That was a point I found people using a lot. 
Of course, fave-bombing just one person might be a bit questionable. 
I will admit, there was a time where I faved almost everything in my inbox,
hence the scary number of favorites I have. (I don't know why there are
that many though, I didn't fave that much?) Though I think that there's
a thin line between adding a few (more than just two or three) to your favorites
and fave-bombing. I often find really good artists with a lot of good art, and 
add the pieces I like the most to my favorites, but I really try not to fave-bomb.
To me, fave-bombing is more annoying than rude. 
On another note, I completely agree with you. You make some really good 
points that I never even thought of including in my original comment. 
We also seen to think alike; I, too, don't see the point in obsessing over
such small things, nor do I really care if people fave my artwork just to get 
attention as I won't give them any. I also just smile and delete the notification.
Reply
:iconthenobleone15:
TheNobleOne15 Featured By Owner Jul 11, 2016  Hobbyist General Artist
Yeah. I really hate it when people try to guilt you when they see you favorite a lot of things. But honestly, who cares? When you think about it, when somebody adds your work to their favorites there's a chance someone will go through their favorites and stumble into your works. In addition, each favorite will probably make your work more likely to appear (correct me if I'm wrong, I've only been a deviant for almost 3 months).

It's just another entrance to your prolife when you think about it. I make sure I don't fave-bomb; I only add about 2-3 works from somebody at the most. To be honest, I don't think many people make a big deal about faving without commenting as I got a lot of 'Thanks for the fav! It really means a lot to me!" on my page.
Reply
:iconswedishfishwolf:
SwedishFishWolf Featured By Owner Jul 11, 2016
That's a smart point. Yeah, if you add someone's work
to your favorites, I guess it appears more. Or at least,
the person stumbling upon your favorites might get the
idea that their work is really good. 

Yeah, I, too, do try really hard not to, but sometimes I just
find these artists where I let it slip. Thought I feel like it's 
been a while since last. 
But yeah, I don't really think that a lot of people actually
care, they just kind of take it and move on. Or they just 
don't speak up about it. (I'm sorry if I'm not making any sense,
It's 5:30 am and I'm tired as heck)
Reply
:icondrama-llama10:
Drama-llama10 Featured By Owner Jan 10, 2016  Hobbyist General Artist
Good indeed.
Reply
:iconsairenko:
Sairenko Featured By Owner Jan 5, 2016  Hobbyist General Artist
uh that looks pretty cool i might use it ^^
Reply
:iconyouneverknowdear:
YouNeverKnowDear Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2016
//cough YES //cough
Reply
:iconberrypunchrules:
BerryPunchrules Featured By Owner Edited Dec 27, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
I understand the meaning behind this stamp, but when I'm just browsing galleries and favoriting all the art, I don't want to spam the artist with comments on everything I fav. =P "This character is pretty" "I love her color scheme!" and the like is pretty much what I say. :P
Reply
:icondarkflow215:
Darkflow215 Featured By Owner Dec 23, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
i wish people actually did this
it's so discouraging to put in so much effort and then not get any comments
Reply
:iconbeulahtrillium:
BeulahTrillium Featured By Owner Dec 19, 2015  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Great idea, I'm sure this is super useful! 
Reply
:iconbagellord802:
BagelLord802 Featured By Owner Dec 8, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Yes I need this .-.
Reply
:iconremcmaximus:
REMcMaximus Featured By Owner Dec 1, 2015  Hobbyist
How do i attach it to my deviations? every time I copy and paste it, i get the text instead of the Icon.
Reply
:iconmidnaadams:
MidnaAdams Featured By Owner Nov 29, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
If the artist's not going to reply, why should I?
Reply
:iconswedishfishwolf:
SwedishFishWolf Featured By Owner Jan 11, 2016
Why isn't there a like-button for comments..
Reply
:iconassassinendergirl:
Assassinendergirl Featured By Owner Nov 25, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
I favorite something because I like it, or I find it helpful. Now it's insulting if I like a lot of things? I'm not referring to the stamp specifically, I'm talking about all the people in the comments that complain about people with a lot of favorites. Yes, I like art, suprise!
Reply
:iconwarnersegamaster:
warnersegamaster Featured By Owner Nov 4, 2015
Why does it even matter?
Reply
:iconlumi-pearl:
Lumi-Pearl Featured By Owner Nov 13, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
^^^^^^^^^^^^
Reply
:icontrumpetcat:
trumpetcat Featured By Owner Nov 3, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
yep, i'll work forever on something, submit it, and be delighted when it gets a fave. then i'll go to the person's profile and see that they favourite EVERYTHING.
Reply
:iconcrimsonknightgallant:
crimsonknightgallant Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
how do i get it to start using it
Reply
:iconstarlightxsword:
StarlightXSword Featured By Owner Edited Nov 8, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
If you still don't know ^^ ;
Scroll down to find the thumb code on the right side of the page → 
It should be something like this: ( :thumb43231916: ) and you can copy and paste it onto your profile to use it.
Reply
:iconcrimsonknightgallant:
crimsonknightgallant Featured By Owner Nov 8, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
so i have t paste on my profile? how?
Reply
:iconstarlightxsword:
StarlightXSword Featured By Owner Edited Nov 8, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
If you're on your computer, click the thumb code so the whole thing would be highlighted, then right click. (If you're on mobile, tap and hold till "copy" comes up) "Copy" and then go to your profile, for e.g. your deviant ID, edit widget, then "paste" the code into your bio.
Reply
:iconcrimsonknightgallant:
crimsonknightgallant Featured By Owner Nov 8, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
ok thx
Reply
:iconstarlightxsword:
StarlightXSword Featured By Owner Nov 8, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
You're welcome
Reply
:iconcrimsonknightgallant:
crimsonknightgallant Featured By Owner Nov 8, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
^^
Reply
:iconminami-yui:
Minami-Yui Featured By Owner Oct 17, 2015  Student Interface Designer
- Using! Thanks
Reply
:iconbabyb01:
BabyB01 Featured By Owner Oct 10, 2015  Student Digital Artist
I've looked at the previous comment and some seem really negative. In my opinion I prefer comments than favourites because I want to know how it looks and to get feedback on what needs to be fixed.
Reply
:iconuniquejack:
UniqueJack Featured By Owner Oct 10, 2015  Hobbyist
Ungrateful much?
Reply
:icon22funday:
22Funday Featured By Owner Edited Oct 9, 2015  Student Digital Artist
:iconcommentplz: :thumb43231916:
Reply
:iconrunisu:
runisu Featured By Owner Oct 6, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
this is so stupid. you did great job creating this stamp, but people asking for comments just make me sad.
if i have something to say about your piece, more than "cute", "amazing" or "you did good" then i'll do it.
it doesn't mean that your art is bad, just becouse you don't get many comments! i'm pretty sure, that many people who agree with that stamp, faved and ran away. 
appreciate what you get!
Reply
:iconbogus-banana:
Bogus-Banana Featured By Owner Dec 17, 2015
This. ^^^
Reply
:iconbubsby:
Bubsby Featured By Owner Sep 24, 2015
Oh, how dare I.
Reply
:iconpink-cake123:
Pink-Cake123 Featured By Owner Sep 22, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Using :3
Reply
:iconimafluffyyunicorn:
ImaFluffyyUnicorn Featured By Owner Sep 18, 2015  Student General Artist
Using ;u; 
Reply
Add a Comment:
 
×





Details

Submitted on
November 17, 2006
Image Size
45.9 KB
Resolution
99×56
Link
Thumb
Embed

Stats

Views
129,230 (14 today)
Favourites
5,774 (who?)
Comments
3,806

License

Creative Commons License
Some rights reserved. This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 License.
×